Waist Size Beat BMI Alone at Flagging Death Risk in a Study of 844,000 Adults

A Nature study of 844,108 adults found a large waist, not a high BMI alone, tracked higher death risk. Here's how to check your waist-to-height ratio.

A large study published in Nature on 11 November 2026 found that a high body mass index (BMI) on its own did not track a higher risk of death. What did was a large waist, measured either as waist size or as waist size compared with height. People whose BMI put them in the obese range but whose waist measures were not high had no clear increase in death risk during a median of 11 to 15 years of follow-up. People in the overweight BMI range who did have a large waist carried about the same extra risk as people with a BMI over 30 and a large waist.

You can check your own waist-to-height ratio at home in a minute with a tape measure.

This post contains one Amazon affiliate link. As an Amazon Associate, Stacking Years earns from qualifying purchases.

What the study found

The paper is a peer-reviewed analysis of human data from four large cohorts, led by An Pan and Francesco Rubino. It tested a new way of diagnosing obesity proposed by a Lancet Commission in 2025. That framework keeps BMI as a first screen but asks doctors to confirm excess body fat with waist size, waist-to-height ratio or a body scan (DXA) before calling it obesity.

The researchers used records from 844,108 adults aged 18 to 74 in China (Kailuan Study), the UK (UK Biobank), the US (All of Us) and Spain (SIDIAP). Everyone was free of stroke, heart attack and cancer at the start. The death analysis used the three cohorts with long enough follow-up: 625,264 people and 51,792 deaths, with median follow-up of 15.3 years in China, 13.8 years in the UK and 11.2 years in Spain.

Compared with people who were not overweight or obese by BMI (under 25, or under 24 in the Chinese cohort):

When the researchers also looked at organ health, the gap widened. People with excess fat plus signs that it was harming the body, such as heart failure, knee or hip arthritis, sleep apnoea, kidney disease or fatty liver with scarring, had a 69% higher risk of death. People with excess fat but normal organ function (called preclinical obesity) had a 19% higher risk. Over 10 years, most people in that second group did not move on to organ problems.

BMI alone also put people in the wrong box. Between 1.2% and 3.1% of people in each cohort were labelled obese by BMI without having a large waist. Between 5.2% and 8.6% were labelled merely overweight even though their waist measures were at obesity level.

Where the waist-to-height line fell

The study did not use the common rule of thumb of 0.5. For white adults, the cut-offs were 0.57 for men and 0.58 for women, with slightly different values for other ethnic groups.

In the data, risk of death began to rise at a waist-to-height ratio of around 0.55. People between 0.50 and those higher cut-offs had no clear increase in death risk. People above them had a 21% higher risk. Using 0.50 instead would have labelled far more people as having a high waist-to-height ratio. In UK Biobank, 66.7% of participants met the 0.50 line, compared with 27.2% using the higher cut-offs.

Limits of the evidence

This is observational data. It shows which measurements line up with earlier death, not that shrinking your waist will add a set number of years. The analysis used existing health records, and organ problems were picked up from diagnosis codes rather than a standard clinical exam, so some will have been missed or misclassified. Not all cohorts recorded every type of organ problem.

The extra risk tied to a large waist in the death analysis was small (6% to 7%). The bigger jumps came with organ damage. The study only included people up to age 74, and the diagnosis rules only used waist cut-offs to confirm obesity in people whose BMI was already in the overweight or obese range (25 or higher, or 24 or higher in the Chinese cohort). People with a lower BMI were not classed as obese even if their waist was large. Several authors report consulting fees or grants from companies that make obesity drugs.

The authors checked whether the results were driven by people who were already ill and losing weight. Leaving out deaths in the first 5 years did not change the pattern, and it held in never-smokers too.

Evidence grade: moderate for the link between waist measures and death risk. The data are large and consistent across four countries, and they fit older findings, but they are observational.

Why it matters

A waist measure is not a new idea. A 2008 study in the New England Journal of Medicine followed 359,387 adults in nine European countries for a mean of 9.7 years. Even after accounting for BMI, men with waists in the largest fifth had about twice the risk of death of those in the smallest fifth, and women had a 78% higher risk. BMI still mattered in that study too.

What the new paper adds is scale and a clear test of the new diagnosis rules. For anyone told their BMI is "obese" while their waist is modest, it is reassuring. For anyone with a BMI in the 25 to 29 range and a thick middle, it is a nudge to take the waist seriously. BMI cannot tell muscle from fat or show where fat sits. NICE notes that fat carried around the middle is linked with type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure and heart disease.

For people over 65, the UK's NICE guideline already says to interpret BMI with caution, partly because of the possible protective effect of a slightly higher BMI in older age.

How to measure your waist-to-height ratio

This is the method in the NICE guideline on overweight and obesity:

1. Find the bottom of your ribs and the top of your hips.

2. Wrap a tape measure around your waist midway between them. That is usually just above the belly button.

3. Breathe out naturally, then read the tape.

4. Measure your height in the same units, both in centimetres or both in inches.

5. Divide your waist by your height. A 96.5 cm waist and a 170 cm height give 0.57.

NICE tells adults with a BMI under 35 to "try and keep their waist to less than half their height (so a waist-to-height ratio of under 0.5)". It classes 0.4 to 0.49 as healthy, 0.5 to 0.59 as increased central fat with increased health risks such as type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure and heart disease, and 0.6 or more as further increased risk. If your result is 0.5 or higher, NICE suggests asking a health professional about a heart and metabolic risk check.

The new study's higher cut-offs were about death, not about diabetes or blood pressure, so they do not replace the 0.5 target. A fair reading is that under 0.5 is the goal, and above about 0.55 is where the death data start to show a difference.

Measure the same way each time and look at the trend over a few months rather than one reading.

As an Amazon Associate, Stacking Years earns from qualifying purchases.

Any soft tape measure works. If you don't have one, you can search for a soft body tape measure on Amazon (affiliate link).

What to do if your number is high

Waist size responds to the same habits that help with weight in general. Our page on keeping a healthy weight covers protein, eating patterns and realistic targets. If you are losing weight, keep an eye on strength as well; grip strength is a simple way to track that side of things.

Because the study found the largest risk where excess fat came with organ problems, a high ratio is also a good reason to check blood pressure, blood sugar (HbA1c) and cholesterol. Our guide to which blood tests to check first is a practical place to start. For people with obesity-related health problems, medicines such as GLP-1 drugs are one option to discuss with a doctor; see our GLP-1 page.

This is general information, not medical advice. Talk to your doctor before major diet changes or if you have a health condition.

FAQ

What is a healthy waist-to-height ratio?

The UK NICE guideline says under 0.5, meaning your waist is less than half your height. It classes 0.5 to 0.59 as increased health risk and 0.6 or more as further increased risk.

Is waist-to-height ratio better than BMI?

They do different jobs. NICE suggests using both for adults with a BMI under 35. In the 2026 Nature study, a high BMI without a large waist was not linked to higher death risk, while a large waist was.

My BMI is over 30 but my waist is under half my height. Am I at risk?

In the Nature study, people with a BMI of 30 to 39.9 (or 28 and over in the Chinese cohort) whose waist measures were below the obesity cut-offs had no clear increase in death risk compared with people who were not overweight or obese by BMI, during a median of 11 to 15 years of follow-up. The estimate was 7% lower, but that is an association, not a guarantee for any one person. Blood pressure, blood sugar, cholesterol and joint health still matter, so a check-up is worthwhile.

Get the free Longevity Supplement Starter Guide

Sign up for the guide and occasional Stacking Years updates. The guide is available on the confirmation screen.

Sources

Related interventions

Related experts